Candidates' positions are categorized as Pro (Yes), Con (No), Not Clearly Pro or Con, or None Found. Candidates who have changed their positions are listed as Now their most recent position.
Is the Current Student/Teacher Ratio of 25-32 Students per Teacher Acceptable?
"The average private school class is about 20-22 students. Public Schools can not be held on the same standard and while it could be reduced, I don't think it is the districts most pressing issue at the moment." Oct. 1, 2014 Patty Finer
"For the vast majority of age ranges and subjects, class sizes over 25 are clearly harmful to both the learning outcomes of students and a major burden to teachers who wish to teach their material properly. As a teacher, I know that classes over 24 students become difficult to teach in small groups. With 24 students, a teacher can split students into four groups of six students. Each group can be working collaboratively and/or with the teacher or teacher's aide. While groups of seven might seem similar, as the group size exceeds five or six, the benefits of small group work are rapidly lost. While there are times where the old fashioned teacher-centered model is appropriate, most times the best learning takes place in smaller groups. Large class sizes impact the teacher's ability to regularly assign meaningful homework too. Meaningful homework involving problem solving, unique solutions, creative or academic writing, independent research, or so many other critical 21st century tasks becomes exponentially burdensome to grade, provide personal feedback, and/or remediate as class size grows. The risk of large class size is less engaged, less creative classrooms, regardless of teacher commitment or skill." Oct. 1, 2014 Craig Foster
"In an ideal world, student/teacher ratios would be reduced slightly below current ratios. The current SMMUSD contract with SMMCTA provides that 'Whenever administratively practical and whenever the District's financial resources allow and facilities permit, the District shall make every effort to maintain elementary classes at thirty (30) or less... maintain middle school classes at thirty-four (34) or less, and high school classes at thirty-five (35) or less...,' implicitly recognizing these as 'acceptable.'
Above these levels, it is difficult for teachers to give students the attention they need. The cost of reducing class sizes below these levels given current State funding would require substantial cuts in program or substantial increases in revenue.
In reality, the District is moving toward a student/teacher ratio of 24:1 in K-3, between 25:1-30:1 in Grades 4-5. Most secondary school classes have ratios of 35:1 or less. Class assignments must take into account numerous considerations, including whether student rosters include children with special needs, keeping siblings in the same school even though different grade levels might be impacted, whether a secondary school teacher has an overall acceptable class ratio even though one class might exceed 35:1, and the availability of 'singleton' classes, such as Calculus DE or Chinese 4." Oct. 1, 2014 Laurie Lieberman
"An acceptable student/teacher ratio depends on the kind of class and the financial resources of the school district. For the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District, I would recommend the following: Avoid having more than 37 pupils in Physical Education classes, avoid having more than 12 pupils in most Special Education classes, and avoid having more than 25 pupils in most general education classes (including Advanced Placement classes).
However, ultimately, it is not so much the size of the class as it is the quality of the teaching that that takes place in the class that matters most. Of course, while the quality of teaching is largely dependent on the instructor, the quality of materials available to the instructor and requirements of the curriculum also make a significant difference." Oct. 1, 2014 Dhun May
"The student/teacher ratio impacts the time a teacher has to interact directly with individual students, the structure of the work product the teacher requires of the student and the general classroom working environment.
Unfortunately, in California, which funds education per student 47th in the US, larger class sizes are the norm in order to maintain a broad spectrum of academic opportunities for our students.
Through the Vision for Student Success program, the district is providing trained Instructional Assistants in all elementary classrooms for a few hours per day and Literacy Coaches in all schools providing support for our teachers. Additionally, through Linked Learning our teachers are collaborating to provide more student-focused lessons. The solution to providing smaller class sizes is to increase funding for our schools so that we can maintain our wide spectrum of academic and arts classes while reducing the teacher/student ratio." Oct. 1, 2014 Ralph Mechur
"In my view, the student/teacher ratio is one of the most significant factors in closing the achievement gap. Students need to be seen by their teachers and teachers need time to connect with their students.
Currently, teachers at the upper grades get roughly one minute of individualized instruction per student once course material is presented. This is not adequate.
We must rely on teachers and their expertise in identifying a ratio that is best to address the achievement gap and to ensure that a joy of learning is not diminished in our classrooms." Oct. 1, 2014 Richard Tahvildaran-Jesswein